Innings and Outings
October 2, 2008 2008, Boston Red Sox, Brian Fuentes, Clay Buchholz, Garrett Atkins, Ian Kennedy, Kyle Kendrick, Matt Cain, Matt Holliday, New York Yankees, Philadelphia Phillies, Philip Hughes, Playoffs, San Francisco Giants, Willy Taveras Comments OffThe season ended on a low note, being swept by the Diamondbacks in Arizona. The games were absolutely meaningless. Quite different from last year when the Diamondbacks and rockies finished the season in Denver with the division title and the NL wildcard on the line. This season, the Tampa Bay Rays are the darlings of a postseason that shows signs of being fun to watch. Without the rockies in the playoffs, I have to return to my traditional ritual of deciding which teams I am rooting for and which ones I am not. Let’s identify the teams I will definitely not be rooting for: Red Sox, nope; Dodgers, nope; Cubs, NOPE! This leaves the Brewers, Phillies, Angels, Rays and White Sox. The Rays are the best story of the season, but a World Series win for them would make the rockies the only modern expansion team without a WS Championship, so I’m not inclined to root for them exclusively. A win for the Phillies would only fuel the bias of the media that already barely acknowledges that baseball exists outside of the east coast. The Angels have in many ways become a member of the “spend until we get it right” club, and have thus eliminated themselves from consideration. Also, they’re kind of like a cousin to the Dodgers, so that association, no matter how remote or off base, further removes them from the list of favorable candidates. This leaves the Brewers and White Sox. The rockies benefited last season from the Brewers playing games 161 and 162 like they meant something. If the Brewers had packed it in against the Padres, then there wouldn’t have been a play-in game and Rocktober never would have happened. So, nothing against the White Sox, but I will personally be rooting for the wide bodies of C.C. Sabathia and Prince Fielder and the rest of the Brew Crew to go deep into the playoffs.
Clint Hurdle and Dan O’Dowd met on Monday and admitted that changes are pending, both with the coaching staff and the roster. The past couple of off-seasons have seen almost no changes to the coaching staff and minor changes to the roster. This year we will likely see major changes in both. Most notably, mainstays such as Matt Holliday, Garrett Atkins and Brian Fuentes will probably be in different uniforms come Opening Day 2009. The starting centerfielder the last two seasons, Willy Taveras, could be dealt in the offseason as well. Of the four, Fuentes is the only one not under team control and he will take the best contract offer, which will not come from the Rockies. If Holliday, Atkins and Taveras are no longer with the team, it will mean that they left via trade.
O’Dowd has indicated Holliday and Atkins are available for pitching. Let’s take a look at some trade possibilities involving Holliday. One potential deal mentioned involving Holliday would be to San Francisco for Matt Cain. If we are going to trade Holliday, then this is the kind of deal I would be in favor of. Cain is a young, yet established pitcher that would make any rotation immensely better. I don’t think this trade will happen though. San Francisco GM Brian Sabean has indicated that Cain is untouchable. In addition, Sabean has stated very clearly that Fred Lewis will be his leftfielder in 2009. Even if San Francisco were to entertain the idea of trading Cain, a reluctance to deal within the division might mean that this offer wouldn’t make it to the table from either side. Another possible destination for Holliday is the Yankees. The Yankees have two young pitchers, Philip Hughes and Ian Kennedy, but neither has established themselves as a member of the NY rotation, both splitting time between the majors and minors this season. The Yankees don’t have much else that would interest the rockies. The other usual suspect when a big-money player is being discussed is Boston. The Red Sox have Clay Buchholz, a 24-year old righty who threw a no-hitter in his second major league start in 2007. Buchholz struggled this season, however, and isn’t on the Red Sox’ playoff roster for the Division Series. For this deal to make sense, Boston would have to find a seperate trading partner for Jason Bay to clear left field for Holliday. Another team I’ve seen mentioned as a potential suitor for Holliday is Philadelphia. The Phillies have Pat Burrell’s contract expiring at the end of this season, so they could replace him in the lineup with Holliday. The Phillies also have Kyle Kendrick, another 24-year old righty who made his MLB debut in 2007. Kendrick started 30 games for the Phillies in 2008, but isn’t on the roster for the Division Series against the Brewers. The Phillies also have their own upcoming contract issue to contemplate with Ryan Howard, so the money that could be used to sign Holliday long-term might go to Howard instead.
My final assessment is that none of these deals will likely happen. They each have their own drawbacks, both from the rockies’ perspective as well as the other teams’ perspectives. The rockies prefer a proven starter in return for Holliday. I don’t see the market out there to support that preference. I think the rockies will end up with a top prospect or two and a couple of fringe prospects. Whether this happens late in the offseason or closer to the trade deadline in 2009, I don’t know.
I’ll take a look at likely destinations for Atkins and Fuentes later.
Until next time, go rockies!
